Author(s): R.A. Hyndman1, S. Dalla1, T. Laitinen1, A. Hutchinson2,3, C.M.S. Cohen4, and R.F. Wimmer-Schweingruber5
Affiliation(s):
1Jeremiah Horrocks Institute, University of Lancashire, Preston, United Kingdom
2Heliophysics Science Division, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA
3Goddard Planetary Heliophysics Institute, University of Maryland, Baltimore County, Baltimore, MD 21250, USA
4California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA;
5Institute of Experimental and Applied Physics, Christian-Albrechts-University Kiel, Leibnizstraße 11, 24118 Kiel, Germany
<< previous nugget — next nugget >>
Introduction
Solar energetic particles (SEPs) can be detected as sporadic increases in the particle intensities by spacecraft in interplanetary space, caused by flares and coronal mass ejections. Typical SEP time-intensity profiles have a rise phase, a peak intensity, and a decay phase. The decay phases, from peak to background levels, can last between a few hours to several days.
The outward flow of the solar wind from the Sun generates magnetic flux tubes that are wound into the Parker spiral by the Sun’s rotation. As the Sun spins, the magnetic flux tubes also rotate with the Sun. This effect is referred to as corotation [1]. From an intuitive point of view, some effects of corotation on SEP intensity profiles are expected. Neglecting significant cross-field diffusion, corotation causes particle-filled magnetic flux tubes to be `pulled’ along westward over time, relative to an observer, after the SEPs are injected into space. This means that when an observer detects an SEP event originated in an eastern solar active region (AR), the filled flux tubes rotate towards them, and when an observer views SEPs from a western region the filled flux tubes rotate away from them. This would affect the observed decay phases, with the latter events in particular being cut short. Recent 3D test-particle modelling of SEPs injected by a wide shock-like source has suggested that corotation affects the decay phases of SEP events [2].
If corotation has a significant effect on the decay phases of SEP events, this east-west difference should be visible in comparisons of the decay-phase duration against the observer location. We investigate SEP decay phases during ten multi-spacecraft events, identifying possible signatures of corotation and comparing the results to those of the simulations [2].
Observations
We study SEP events using multi-spacecraft data. As an example, Figure 1 shows a plot of the location of four spacecraft which detected an SEP event in 2021 with source AR location shown by a black arrow. Here PSP observed the solar event as western, while STEREO-A, Solar Orbiter and SOHO viewed the event as eastern (in relation to the footpoint of the nominal Parker spiral line through each spacecraft).

Figure 1: Spacecraft configurations (top panels) and SEP intensity profiles (bottom panels) for 2021 October 28 event. Spacecraft configurations are from Solar-MACH [3]. Colour-coded circles indicate the spacecraft locations and nominal Parker spirals calculated from measured solar wind speed at the spacecraft. Multi-spacecraft SEP intensity profiles for the proton ~ 25 MeV channel were made using SERPENTINE [4] tools.
We used data from Solar Orbiter, PSP, SOHO, and STEREO-A to create SEP multi-spacecraft intensity-time plots (see Figure 1). We fit the decay phases of the intensity profiles to obtain the value of the decay time constant, τ.
τ = − (d ln I / dt)−1
where I is the particle intensity, and t is time.
To characterise the observer location with respect to the event source AR, we defined Δφ, the difference in longitude between the observer’s magnetic footpoint on the Sun and the AR associated with the event:
Δφ = φAR − φftpt
where φAR is the longitude of the source AR, and φftpt is the longitude of the observer’s magnetic footpoint on
the Sun.
We determined φftpt for each spacecraft using the open-source tool Solar-MACH. φftpt was calculated using the nominal Parker Spiral for each spacecraft based on the solar wind speed, Vsw, taken from CDAWeb (https://cdaweb.gsfc.nasa.gov). When the AR lies west of the footpoint of the spacecraft (western solar events), Δφ > 0. When the AR lies east of the footpoint of the spacecraft (eastern solar events), Δφ < 0.
Results

Figure 2: Decay-time constant τ vs. longitudinal separation Δφ for protons at ~25 MeV. The coloured lines connect s/c data points for a single event. The grey shading shows results from a 25 MeV simulation run following the method of [2, 5]. Error bars are omitted when they are smaller than the data points.
In Figure 2 we plot the decay-time constant, τ , against Δφ for ~ 25 MeV protons for ten events. Data points from multiple spacecraft for the same SEP event have the same colour. We also ran 3D test-particle simulations of SEPs injected from a shock-like source and propagated a mono-energetic, 25 MeV proton population for 72 hours, obtaining the simulated grey shaded curve in Figure 2.
Figure 2 shows that for a given Δφ value, a broad range of τ values are observed. In general, a larger spread and higher τ values are seen for eastern events (Δφ < 0) compared to western events (Δφ > 0). When we consider each event individually, there is a tendency for τ to decrease from east to west for most of the events. This agrees with the trend from the test-particle simulations.
Figure 3: τ against Δφ with each event in a different colour. The best-fit dashed lines are plotted for each event and the gradient values (hrs/degree) of these lines are shown in the key.
To capture the east-west trend for each individual event, we show in Figure 3 the best linear fit to the data points, which corresponds to each event. We call the gradient of these fits dτ / d(Δφ) , and the fits are shown as colour-coded dashed lines in Figure 3.
Figure 4: dτ / d(Δφ) values from the linear fit of τ vs Δφ data points for each event against CME speed. The red line marks the gradient = 0 line.
We plot dτ / d(Δφ) of each event against CME speed in Figure 4. Almost all events have negative gradients, which supports the hypothesis of higher τ values in the east and lower τ values in the west. Two events have positive gradients, but both of these values are low. On the whole, a trend for higher eastern τ values and lower western τ values is seen.
Conclusion
We have analysed ten SEP events with four observing spacecraft, with a focus on the decay phase. We determined the decay-time constant, τ, and studied its dependence on Δφ, which is the longitudinal separation between the source AR and observer footpoint location at the Sun. We have seen that within individual events there is a trend of decreasing τ values for increasingly western ARs (increasing Δφ). This is in line with the trend obtained from recent simulations investigating the effect of corotation of the magnetic field lines with the Sun on SEP intensity profiles. We conclude that these observations point towards corotation having an important effect on SEP transport and the resulting profiles seen at observers at different heliolongitudes. Corotation should therefore be included in future SEP models and interpretations of SEP events.
Publication link: https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/abs/2025/02/aa53012-24/aa53012-24.html
References
[1] McCracken, K. G., Rao, U. R., Bukata, R. P., & Keath, E. P. 1971, Sol. Phys., 18, 100.
[2] Hutchinson, A., Dalla, S., Laitinen, T., & Waterfall, C. O. G. 2023a, A&A, 670, L24.
[3] Gieseler, J., Dresing, N., Palmroos, C., et al. 2023, Front. astron. space sci., 9.
[4] Dresing, N., Yli-Laurila, A., Valkila, S., et al. 2024, A&A 687 A72
[5] Hutchinson, A., Dalla, S., Laitinen, T., & Waterfall, C. O. G. 2023b, A&A, 670, A178